Inset vs. overlay cabinets: Which is right for your kitchen?

Considering a new cabinet set as part of your kitchen remodel? The decision between inset and overlay cabinets can significantly impact the overall look and functionality of your space. 

Inset cabinets feature doors and drawers that fit flush inside the cabinet frame for a seamless appearance. In contrast, overlay cabinets have doors and drawers that rest on top of the frame, with options for full, half, or partial coverage. 

Although this might seem like a slight distinction, the cabinet style you choose has major ramifications in terms of style, function, and cost. This inset vs. overlay cabinet guide breaks down the differences between these popular cabinet styles, helping you make an informed decision as you create your perfect kitchen.

Inset cabinets

Inset kitchen cabinets are a classic and sophisticated choice. With their distinctive design, the doors and drawer fronts of inset cabinets sit within the cabinet frame, creating a flush, streamlined appearance. Their built-in style offers a clean, refined look that adds a touch of elegance to any kitchen. Inset cabinets require precise craftsmanship and attention to detail, making them popular for those seeking a high-end, custom look.

It’s important to note that inset kitchen cabinets require precise measurements and installation, which can increase the overall price tag — they cost about 15% to 30% more than overlay cabinets, according to Angi. 

Additionally, inset cabinets tend to provide slightly less storage space than overlay cabinets since the cabinet doors and drawers take up interior space. However, many homeowners appreciate the contemporary aesthetic and craftsmanship of inset cabinets.

Shaker vs. Raised vs. Mission inset cabinets

Among the various styles for inset cabinets, shaker, raised, and mission inset cabinets stand out due to their aesthetic appeal and adaptability to different kitchen styles. 

• Shaker inset cabinets’ simplistic, yet stylish design is characterized by a recessed center panel and a minimalistic, clean-lined frame. 
• Raised inset cabinets feature a center panel that stands out from the rest of the door, creating a more detailed-rich, traditional look. 
• Mission-style inset cabinets, inspired by the Arts and Crafts movement, boasts straightforward lines and sturdy construction, emphasizing craftsmanship and natural materials. 

Each style has a unique charm, and what you ultimately choose hinges on personal preference and the ambiance of your kitchen.

Estimated cost breakdown

The cost of inset cabinets fluctuates based on factors such as the cabinet wood species, design intricacy, and cabinet size. Generally, inset cabinets range from $150 to $1,200 per linear foot, depending on the quality of materials you choose. 

Keep in mind that inset cabinets typically are pricier than their overlay counterparts. This higher cost stems from inset cabinetry’s precise craftsmanship and a meticulous installation process that requires a perfect fit within the frame. 

When investing in inset cabinets, consider your budget, quality goals, and the value they bring to your kitchen’s aesthetic and functionality.

Overlay cabinets

As an alternative to the seamless appearance of inset cabinets, overlay cabinets bring their own appeal through doors and drawer fronts that rest on top of the cabinet frame. This lends to a unique style and feel while often providing design flexibility and a more cost-effective choice. These cabinets’ three prominent styles — full overlay, half overlay, and partial overlay — differ in the amount of cabinet door overlay they feature.

Full overlay vs. half overlay vs. partial overlay

Each variant of overlay cabinets offers a distinct visual appeal and coverage of the cabinet frame. 

• Full overlay cabinets provide a sleek, contemporary appearance by covering almost the entire cabinet frame, leaving only minimal gaps between doors and drawers. This style rivals inset cabinets’ smooth facade but typically costs less. You can get full overlay cabinets to fit any style, including Shaker, traditional, and Craftsman. For example, full overlay Shaker cabinets are a great (and potentially more economical) alternative to inset Shaker cabinets.
• Half overlay cabinets, often referred to as “traditional overlay” or “semi-overlay,” partially cover the cabinet frame, leaving more of the frame visible between doors and drawers. This results in a balanced, classic look that fits particularly well in traditional kitchen designs.
• Partial overlay cabinets, also known as “standard” overlay, expose a significant part of the frame, resulting in a clear frame outline around doors and drawers. As the most common and economical option, partial overlays are great for budget-conscious remodels, rental properties, or starter homes.

Estimated cost breakdown

The cost of overlay cabinets varies wildly depending on factors such as materials, design complexity, and size. In general, overlay cabinets are cheaper than inset cabinets, owing to their less precise construction and installation processes. 

Overlay cabinets cost about 15% to 30% less (about $100 to $1,000 per linear foot) than their inset counterparts, with partial overlay cabinets coming in at the lowest price points. Offering more coverage and a sleeker look, half and full overlay cabinets tend to be more expensive than partial overlay cabinets. 

While less expensive than inset cabinets, overlay cabinets can still provide a desirable aesthetic and practical functionality to your kitchen space.

Pros and cons of inset cabinets

Inset cabinets come with distinct benefits and potential drawbacks. Taking both the pros and cons into account will help you make the best decision as you consider inset vs. overlay cabinets.

Pros of inset cabinets

High-end aesthetic 

Inset cabinets lend an upscale, custom feel to any kitchen. Their design showcases the cabinets’ craftsmanship, as precise measurements go into ensuring the doors and drawers fit perfectly within the cabinet frame. This adds to the aesthetic appeal, and the seamless look can add substantial value to your home.

Increased visibility of cabinet frame

Inset cabinets show more of their frame than overlay styles do. This allows more room for decorative trim and detailing, which is ideal for those looking to add an extra touch of elegance to their kitchen design.

Cons of inset cabinets

Reduced storage space

Another potential drawback of inset cabinets is the slightly reduced storage space. Since the doors and drawers sit inside the cabinet frame, this can slightly reduce the internal storage area compared with overlay cabinets. This is less of an issue for larger kitchens, but every inch of storage counts in smaller spaces.

Potential for warping or sticking 

In climates with high humidity or large temperature fluctuations, inset doors and drawers may warp or stick due to the precise fit required. This isn’t a common problem, but it’s worth considering if you live in an area with these conditions.

Pros and cons of overlay cabinets

Overlay cabinets are popular due to their affordability, flexibility, and practicality. However, as with any design choice, they have their own benefits and downsides. Here are the main pros and cons of adding overlay cabinets to your kitchen.

Pros of overlay cabinets

Cost-effective

One of the major benefits of overlay cabinets is their affordability. They are typically less expensive to produce and install than inset cabinets, making them a popular choice for homeowners on a budget or for large-scale kitchen renovations.

More storage space

Overlay cabinets tend to offer slightly more storage space than inset cabinets. As the doors and drawers sit on top of the cabinet frame, rather than inside it, you get a bit more internal storage area — a significant advantage in smaller kitchens or where maximizing storage is a priority.

Design flexibility

With the options of full, half, and partial overlays, you have more control over how much of the cabinet frame is visible, allowing you to customize the look of your kitchen. From the modern, sleek look of full overlay cabinets to the traditional (and economical) appeal of partial overlay cabinets, there’s an overlay style to suit every aesthetic preference.

Cons of overlay cabinets

More common aesthetic

While overlay cabinets are flexible and functional, they don’t offer the same high-end, bespoke appearance that inset cabinets do. But this doesn’t mean they can’t look fantastic. With complementary panels and profiles, overlay cabinets can make any kitchen shine. That said, those seeking a classic, custom-made look may prefer inset cabinets.

Visibility of cabinet frame

Depending on the type of overlay you choose, more of the cabinet frame might be visible. This could be a disadvantage if the drawer fronts or finishes don’t match well with the underlying frame. Full overlay cabinets minimize this issue, as they cover most of the frame.

Choosing between inset and overlay cabinets

Your inset vs. overlay cabinet choice largely comes down to personal preference, budget, the style of your kitchen, and practical needs. Both styles offer unique advantages, and the best choice is the one that meets your specific requirements and complements your kitchen’s overall design. Here are some factors to contemplate when deciding:

Budget

Considering your budget is essential, as inset cabinets generally cost more than overlay cabinets due to the precision needed for their construction and installation. If you’re working within a tight budget, overlay cabinets are a more economical option.

Aesthetic preferences

Your personal design preferences play a significant role in this decision. If you’re aiming for a clean, custom look, inset cabinets are probably the way to go. However, if you don’t mind more of the cabinet frame showing and want to save a few bucks, overlay cabinets are a great alternative with plenty of attractive, modern options.

Storage needs

Think about your storage needs. Overlay cabinets typically provide a tad more storage space, as the doors and drawers sit on top of the cabinet frame rather than inside it. If you have a smaller kitchen or need to maximize storage, this could be a deciding factor.

Kitchen layout

The layout of your kitchen can also influence your decision. Inset cabinets might be more suitable for smaller kitchens as they create a streamlined look, making the space appear larger and more cohesive.

While weighing these factors, don’t hesitate to seek professional advice or use our online tools to help visualize how each style would look in your kitchen. The Cabinet Door Store is here to provide the resources and expertise you need to make the best choice for your unique space.

Here’s a quick side-by-side comparison of each style:

Stay updated with The Cabinet Door Store 

Now that you understand the differences between inset and overlay cabinets, it’s time to take the next step in transforming your kitchen. The Cabinet Door Store is here to help you every step of the way, browse our wide selection of cabinet doors, drawer fronts, panels, and profiles. 

Whether you’re planning a cabinet refacing project or a complete kitchen remodel, our team is dedicated to providing you with high-quality products and excellent customer service. If you have any questions or need guidance, provide us your email, and our team of experienced professionals will be happy to assist you.